Whoever would have thought that hospital car parking would have generated so much political heat?
Lee Waters' post on the Our Kingdon blog (http://ourkingdom.opendemocracy.net/2008/03/04/wisdom-of-welsh-parking-obscured-by-context-of-devolution/) tries to get us back on track and remind us that there needs to be a debate about how free car parking at hospital sites contributes to carbon reduction targets, which of course it doesn't. But, as I have thought about this over the day, I think it is an important issue of social justice.
First, there are surely places where charges should be levied long before hospitals. The gigantic car parks at retail parks and supermarkets all provide free parking, as do many public buildings. Our concern about carbon emissions caused by hospital car parking is a little misplaced with so many other offenders. Second, people have little choice about whether or not to visit a hospital - they need to go for treatment or to visit relatives - unlike popping over to B&Q on a Sunday afternoon. And third, and critically, public transport to many hospitals is rubbish - it can take 2 or 3 buses which don't connect to get from Bedlinog to Prince Charles Hospital in Merthyr for example - and if you are going for treatment, even as an outpatient, chances are you won't feel like a 2 hour bus journey.
So, unless and until there is no free parking in most other places, free hospital car parking has to stay.
Tuesday, 4 March 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Posts
1 comments:
Hello
Thanks for visiting my blog I will link you. I have a lot of respect for the Bevan Foundations recent work.
I agree on the social justice element of this whole debate.
When it comes to cost then people who are having treatment, and have to park, or be taken to hospital and friends and relatives and incur costs often can ill afford it. When people are visiting often terminal relatives and friends the last thing they need to worry about is finding money and ticket machines.
Trusts have budget for maintenance of their buildings and capital assets. I do not like the thought of money being taken from parking cars to run hospitals.
I do not see this as a green issue, and the green lobby needs to stop band wagon jumping, it dilutes their cause.
I think if we are looking at wider justice, motorists pay enough anyway, how much of the tax we pay goes to the roads and services for motorists, not a lot, then we pay even more. Why pay at superstores, they make enough money to subsidise any costs. There are a multitude of issues around parking and parking charges, it goes back to availability and cost of public transport. As you said this is a layered issue.
Post a Comment